The Real Reasons Most Real Estate Agents Fail

Why most agents struggle — and how you can avoid becoming part of the 87%

The statistics are tough: a large percentage of new agents leave the industry within their first five years. But why is that? Is real estate really that difficult, or are agents simply approaching it the wrong way? The truth is, most agents don’t fail because they lack talent — they fail because they lack clarity, systems, and accountability. In this blog, we’ll uncover the real reasons most real estate agents fail and how coaching can help you avoid becoming part of the statistic.

Lack of Clarity in Goals and Vision

Many agents dive into real estate chasing freedom and high commissions, but without a clear plan, they quickly get lost.

  • No clear income goals.
  • No defined niche or target market.
  • No long-term vision for their business.

Without clarity, agents spread themselves too thin, reacting to opportunities instead of building a strategic path forward.

Relying on Hustle Instead of Systems

Hustle Burns Out

In the beginning, hustle can get you clients. Cold calls, open houses, and late nights may bring short-term wins. But hustle alone isn’t sustainable.

Systems Create Predictability

Top agents build systems — for lead generation, client follow-up, and transaction management. Systems create consistency, reduce stress, and make growth possible.

This is why John Kitchens often says: “Systems beat hustle every time.”

Poor Lead Generation and Follow-Up

One of the biggest reasons why real estate agents fail is inconsistency with leads:

  • They chase leads randomly instead of having a proven process.
  • They fail to follow up consistently, losing clients to more disciplined agents.
  • They lack a pipeline that ensures steady deals every month.

With structured lead generation systems, agents can move from feast-or-famine cycles to predictable growth.

No Accountability

When you’re your own boss, no one is holding you to your commitments. Many agents know what they should be doing but don’t actually follow through.

This is where real estate agent coaching comes in:

  • A coach provides accountability to ensure action.
  • They help you stay consistent with proven frameworks.
  • They keep you focused on the big picture, not just daily distractions.

Lack of Business Mindset

Thinking Like an Agent, Not a CEO

Most agents treat real estate as a job, not a business. They focus only on the next transaction instead of building a scalable model.

The Agent-to-CEO Shift

To succeed long-term, agents must make the agent-to-CEO transformation — moving from doing everything themselves to building systems and teams that run the business.

The Role of Coaching in Preventing Failure

The good news? These pitfalls are avoidable. Coaching provides:

  • Clarity: Helping you define your goals and vision.
  • Systems: Building processes for lead generation, follow-up, and growth.
  • Accountability: Ensuring you execute consistently.
  • Leadership Growth: Teaching you how to move from agent to CEO.

Agents who invest in coaching build businesses designed for success — not survival.

Case Study — From Struggling to Scaling

One agent John Kitchens coached was on the verge of burnout after three years in the business. They were working hard but barely covering expenses. By implementing a clear business plan, lead generation system, and accountability structure, they went from 15 annual transactions to 45 within a year. Coaching provided the clarity and systems that hustle alone never could.

Final Thoughts

The truth is simple: most agents don’t fail because real estate is impossible. They fail because they lack clarity, systems, accountability, and a business mindset. By addressing these areas — and with the support of real estate agent coaching — you can position yourself not just to survive in this industry, but to thrive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do most real estate agents fail?

Most agents fail not because they lack talent, but because they lack clarity, systems, accountability, and a business mindset. Without these, it’s nearly impossible to scale successfully.

How can coaching help a real estate agent succeed?

Coaching provides clarity, accountability, proven systems, and leadership growth. A coach helps you stay consistent and focused, ensuring you build a business that lasts.

What percentage of agents actually succeed?

According to NAR, 87% of agents fail within five years. Only 13% make it — and they do so by building systems, focusing on growth, and investing in coaching and leadership development.

What is the Agent-to-CEO shift?

It’s the transformation from working as an individual agent who does everything to becoming a business owner who leads a team, builds systems, and creates a scalable business model.

Book Your Free Strategy Session

Don’t let yourself become another statistic. Book your free strategy session with John Kitchens today and learn how to build the systems, clarity, and mindset to succeed in real estate.

Book Your Strategy Session

© 2025 John Kitchens Coach. All rights reserved. | Real Estate Coaching That Gets Results